Inspect what would remain
Ask for an assessment of the cabinet boxes, attachment, moisture damage and drawer function. A new front does not correct an unsuitable layout or a failing box.
- Open every door and drawer.
- Record damage near sinks and appliances.
- List storage problems the current layout creates.
Compare the finished result
Write down what each option actually changes. New fronts, hardware and exposed panels may be enough when the room works. Moving appliances or changing cabinet dimensions may point toward replacement.
- Compare door and drawer construction.
- Check whether interiors remain unchanged.
- Include any countertop work triggered by the choice.
Price both against the same expectations
Compare complete proposals rather than a refacing headline price and a cabinet-only replacement price. Ask about cleanup, finish matching and what happens if hidden damage is found.
- State which cabinets are included.
- Ask to see a finish sample.
- Keep optional storage accessories itemized.